How Many Reminders Before It Is Nagging
The question arrives the moment you can see who has not recorded. Four people are silent, the deadline is a week out, and the tool is offering to email them again. Nobody wants to be the person who chased their own family four times for a birthday video.
The reminder counts these tools send are published on their own help pages, so the comparison can be exact rather than rhetorical.
What the tools actually send
Five is a defensible number for a wedding with a hard cut-off and a planner running it. It is the wrong default for a memorial, where the people who have not recorded are frequently the ones who cannot face it yet.
Worth knowing that the company sending five says the same thing we are about to. Tribute’s own help page tells organizers that a message from you personally converts better than anything they send, and points you at copying the link and texting the two or three people who will answer you.
- Tribute: up to five emails to anyone who has not submitted, stopping the moment they do. Their help page names all five: an invitation when you publish, one halfway to the deadline, one the day before, one on the day, and one the day after. Each can be unticked in their settings, and the dates move when you move the deadline.
- videos.me: one. It goes three days before your due date to anyone who has not recorded, and the email says in plain words that it is the only one. With no due date set it goes five days after the invitation, and somebody invited later than that gets none.
What an extra email actually costs
There is no published figure for how many reminders a group video collection can absorb before people start dropping out, and anybody who quotes you one has invented it. What can be reasoned about is the mechanism, and the mechanism is unforgiving.
Every automated reminder carries an unsubscribe link, because the law requires one. A contributor who clicks it is suppressed from then on, which means the next invitation you send that person, for the next occasion, does not arrive either, and nothing tells you that at the time.
So the cost of the fourth email is not irritation. It is losing the address, silently, for every film you make after this one.
The rule that holds up
A message from you outperforms a fourth automated one for three reasons: it comes from somebody they know, it arrives where they already talk to you, and it can answer the actual reason they have not recorded. That reason is almost never the email. It is that they do not know what to say.
- One automated reminder, timed to the deadline rather than to the day you got impatient.
- Then one message from you, written by hand, to the few people whose absence would be felt in the film.
- Then stop, and compile what you have.
What to say in the one nudge
Two versions, because the group chat and the private message do different jobs. The group one gives permission; the private one removes the excuse.
- To the group: “Eleven in so far and they are lovely. If you have not done yours, it is thirty seconds on your phone, no app, and I am putting the film together Thursday night.”
- To one person: “Mum would really want yours in this. If it helps, just answer one question: what is the first thing you think of when you think of her? Record that and stop. I will do the rest.”
When more than one is justified
Hard deadlines earn another message: a funeral, a flight, a surprise party on Saturday. The trick is that the second message should not repeat the ask. It should state the deadline and what happens at it, which is new information rather than pressure.
“I am compiling Thursday night, so anything after that misses the film” gives somebody a reason to act now. “Just a gentle nudge about the video” gives them a reason to feel guilty and do nothing.
How to tell whether it is working
Your invitation page separates the people who opened their link from the people who recorded, and that split is the useful part. Somebody who opened it and stopped has already decided to take part and has got stuck. Somebody who never opened it has not seen the ask.
Those two groups need different sentences. The first needs help knowing what to say; the second needs the link somewhere they will actually look. Sending both of them the same reminder is how a collection stalls at eleven clips.